Collective Agreements in the Public Service

There are considerable occupational differences in state public labour laws and in professional or group trade union organizations. For example, professional firefighters have undoubtedly had the greatest access to collective bargaining rights, resulting in a high union membership rate of 77% (Farber, 2005). Firefighters are only prohibited from negotiating in two states, while only four states allow negotiation as a local option, but the agreements are not legally enforceable. Another 14 states allow collective bargaining for termination as a local option with enforceable agreements, and the other 30 states provide for a bargaining obligation that can allow collective bargaining to be dismissed in 44 states. Amid recent controversies over public employee labor laws, firefighters` collective bargaining has remained stable, although concession negotiations (contracts that require workers to accept lower wages or pay higher contributions to health and pension funds, or both) have been widespread. In contrast, collective bargaining laws for teachers since 2010 have been a significant reform or elimination goal in states such as Idaho, Tennessee, Wisconsin, Michigan, Illinois and Ohio. In 2010, 35 states had laws requiring collective bargaining for teachers, while five states prohibited collective bargaining for teachers; the other states offered various local options, resulting in a 70 per cent teachers` union (Farber 2005). Dissatisfaction with academic performance and achievement, as well as new opportunities to create potentially profitable education enterprises, a financial and economic crisis, and public disregard for perceived superior employment conditions for teachers, have led some politicians to restructure legal frameworks for employment for teachers. This type of political ebb and flow provides some of the differences between professions, states, and eras that this research uses to examine the impact of public sector frameworks. (Updated July 2021) The aim of this overview is to provide the latest information on collective bargaining in the public sector in Europe.

It is based on reports published in EPSU`s bi-monthly collective bargaining bulletin. In 1935, the United States passed the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), which protected the right of private sector workers to collective bargaining. However, the law has remained silent on the issue of civil servants. Due to the lack of federal protection for public servants, the right to collective bargaining varies considerably from state to state. In West Virginia, for example, public sector workers do not have a legal framework for collective bargaining. In North Carolina, public sector workers are expressly prohibited from bargaining collectively. State governments have eroded longstanding collective bargaining laws for wisconsin and Iowa public servants. The largest public sector agreement involving around 350,000 municipal, health and social service workers was negotiated at the end of 2020. The 41-month agreement runs until September 31.

March 2024 and includes general salary increases of 2% in 2020 (with an average value of SEK 520 (EUR 50), an additional 2% (SEK 530 (EUR 51)) in 2021 and 1.4% (SEK 380 (EUR 37)) in 2022. A supplement of 0.6% is granted for professional occupations in each of the three years and a lump sum of SEK 5 500 (EUR 535) for all employees in the first year. The salary increase in 2023 will be negotiated later. The improvement of conditions includes the reduction of night working time from 36.2 hours per week to 34.2 hours; a permanent job offer for persons on fixed-term contracts after 18 months instead of 24 months; and entitlements to additional leave related to leave agreed upon at the request of the employer. In Utah, there is no law requiring a public sector institution to recognize a union. And finally, there has been a law in Wyoming for several years that explicitly allows firefighters to bargain if they vote to form a union. There are multifaceted negotiations at various levels of government – local, regional and federal. Recent developments have been in the health sector with an agreement at the federal level that also covers the private sector. .

Published