The Supreme Court ruled for the third time in this case and in this recent decision, the Supreme Court ruled quite differently from the last decision, declaring that the official memorandum of understanding, as registered with the authorities, is the valid agreement that governs the relationship between the parties, not the ancillary agreement. While the company`s memorandum of understanding and business license may reflect de jure ownership, sub-agreements can help the foreign shareholder protect their interests and ensure that they have control of the company. A literal interpretation of the provision renders most ancillary agreements illegal and void from the outset. Article 395 of the UAE Civil Code states that if the contracting parties hide a real contract with an apparent contract, the real contract will be effective as there have been serious criticisms of the contract design that have clearly affected the UAE`s efforts to include more domestic operators in its economy. A “parallel agreement” to the memorandum of articles and association of a limited liability company is considered illegal, but is still being considered by the UAE`s highest courts, a senior lawyer and legal adviser said yesterday. It would be inconsistent with the UAE government`s pro-business stance to restrict or ban side agreements. This would only discourage foreign investors from investing in the UAE. Although the legality and applicability of ancillary agreements are always questioned, these types of agreements, although very complicated, are and are used very frequently in the United Arab Emirates. However, one option to improve the position of a foreign minority shareholder could be to avoid the problem by establishing a branch in the UAE of a foreign company instead of a UAE LLC. The branch requires the appointment of a national representative of the United Arab Emirates, but the representative has no ownership or administrative rights over the activities of the branch.
The Supreme Court relied on Articles 8, 10 and 11 of the Commercial Companies Act (CCL) and ruled that it is essential that all agreements on commercial companies be written, notarized and registered in the Commercial Register to comply with the requirements of the CDC, and that any changes to the company`s documents (i.e. the articles of association) are also duly notarized and registered in the same way. must be like the memorandum of understanding. Article 675(2) provides that `it is also permissible to conclude an agreement between the other members on the continuation of the company if one of them dies or is subject to a legal restriction or goes bankrupt or shares, and in such cases that partner or his heirs are entitled only to his share of the company`s assets …` the Federal Court set aside the judgment of the Court of Appeal and referred the case back to the Court of Appeal for reconsideration of the appeal and the instructions of the Supreme Court. Given the legal scenario, foreign investors have resorted to ancillary structures to hold their controlling financial interests in their Emirati companies. Therefore, it is common in the UAE for shareholders to enter into “registered shareholder agreements” (NSAs) or “parallel agreements” between the parties. Under the NSA, a UAE national agrees to waive all rights nominally held by the LLC, the rights to receive dividends similar to dividends, to vote at general meetings, and to draw proceeds from the sale of the shares. In short, the NSA`s regulations circumvent UAE corporate law. The NSA or silent agreement prevents the UAE`s majority shareholder from participating in the LLC`s operations, making the foreign partner the sole beneficiary and decision-maker of the company. The UAE investor has appealed to the Supreme Court for the third time to challenge the validity of the ancillary agreement, and it is this appeal that is the subject of this update.
Although the general intent in contract law is that an ancillary agreement establishes legally enforceable rights and obligations and has the same force as the underlying main contract. However, this is by no means guaranteed. In some cases, the courts have denied the validity of the ancillary agreement and have concluded that a side agreement has nothing more than moral effect. Therefore, ancillary agreements (usually between two contracting parties) need to be carefully worked out. Collateral contracts are often used in commercial contracts, especially in financial or real estate transactions. An ancillary agreement usually comes in the form of a letter signed by the signatory parties to the main contract. For an ancillary agreement to become binding, it must meet the same standard as all contracts, i.e. there should be an offer, acceptance, consideration, certainty and the intention to establish a legal relationship. An ancillary contract is a contract for which consideration (payment, in any form, as part of the contract) must be provided. The consideration condition is the most important in an ancillary agreement and does not necessarily have to be in monetary form; it can only be a mutual benefit. It is important to note that in the absence of benefit or payment, an ancillary agreement can only become legally binding if it is signed as an act, which means that it must indicate that the ancillary agreement is an act and that the signatures of the party must be attested. In a dispute between an investor from the United Arab Emirates and a foreign investor, the parties argued over whether a parallel agreement or the formal memorandum of association governed their relations.
The vae investor insisted that the formal memorandum of understanding is the valid document, while the foreign investor argued that the ancillary agreement states that the foreign investor has a higher percentage of shares and that the ancillary agreement is the valid/enforceable agreement to govern the relationship between the two parties. An ancillary agreement is usually designed to be used in commercial contracts and comes in the form of a letter signed by the signatory parties to the main contract. .