Unfortunately, in many situations, lawyers draft these types of contracts in English without taking into account the other languages involved in the transactions. The most common languages for multilingual business contracts are English, Chinese, Korean, German, Spanish, and Russian. Sometimes, at the last second, lawyers think about adding a basic text module that states that English is the “official language” of the contract – essentially, at the same time, they acknowledge and reject the fact that the other party is not native English. The obvious arrogance and dismissive tone with which this clause is often formulated undermines otherwise cordial multicultural trade negotiations. Some States have also adopted special rules for translations. For example, Texas Rule of Evidence 1009 provides a general overview of the admission and rejection of foreign language translations as documentary evidence. The translation of a document into a foreign language is in principle permitted provided that it is accompanied by an affidavit from a qualified translator in a foreign language indicating the translator`s qualifications and the translation being fair and accurate. There are also procedures for serving the document on the other party and for opposing the translation. For states that do not have this type of rules of evidence, parties may still refer to the Texas rule as a guideline for maintaining an adequate record of the reliability of the translation offered. This article suggests that there are reasons to pay much more attention to the issue of language choice. From drafting the contract to introducing proof of dispute, using a multilingual contract will show your clients that you are an accomplished lawyer who knows how to look after their best interests. Therefore, many companies that enter into international contracts will choose to include a language choice clause in their agreements.
In many cases, international commercial contracts have a language choice clause that identifies English as the official version of the contract, as English is often the common language between the parties. Why is this necessary? The contract law of most nations follows the well-known principle that there must be a meeting of minds in order to establish a binding treaty. If it does not exist, there is no contract. Each foreign nation has different rules of proof of what is admissible as evidence if it is proved what the parties understood they received for the benefit of the agreement. Many laws allow the use of Parol evidence. For example, the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods allows the courts that apply it to take into account “all relevant circumstances” of the contract – this would apply to both the contract in the original language and the translation (see e.B. MCC-Marble Ceramic Center, Inc.c. Ceramica Nuova D`Agostino, S.p.A., 144 F.3d 1384 (11th Cir. 1998)). The use of Parol evidence is even more applicable if the translation was signed by both parties and the translation dealt with a subject or scenario that appeared to omit the original language. The unfortunate result is that the courts (or arbitral tribunals) will have to rule on these types of cases, as it is less likely that the parties will be able to settle their own disputes amicably. Instead, they will all believe that their own interpretation of the treaty is feasible and will spend far too much money to discuss that interpretation.
ICC model contracts and clauses aim to create a solid legal basis on which parties to international treaties can quickly reach a balanced agreement acceptable to both parties. The reason is simple: if you plan to plead before a Chinese (or foreign) court, the staff of that court will not speak English. You will not read English. Even if they read English, the Rules of Procedure of the Court will require that the documents be translated into the national language. If you have already determined that the party with whom you are entering into a contract has no assets outside their own country and that redress in local courts is faster than arbitration, why would you ever want to have a contract in English that spoils these foreign proceedings? The only language that the foreign court will deal with is his own, and contracts that are in several languages will confuse the problem. A single contract in a single language (that of the jurisdiction that sees and applies it every day) will make the procedure faster, cheaper and easier – three words that make customers very happy. The first thing the parties should consider when dealing with foreign parties is whether the final contract should be in English, in the foreign language, or both. If the contract is written in more than one language, which one is official? What control in case of conflict? In the case of international business transactions, the two parties may not have a common language. In these circumstances, the final contract may be translated into several languages, and there may be up to two or three different language versions of the same agreement. Therefore, it is important to indicate by means of a language choice clause which language is the “official” version of the contract. While a good translation of a contract by a lawyer will try to stay as close as possible to the original, the act of translation will inevitably subtly change the meaning of some parts of the agreement. In the absence of a language choice clause, this can lead to problems later if the contract has to be interpreted by a court and it is not clear which version the official agreement is.
Below are two classic examples of language selection clauses: Your customer may tell you, “I can`t read a Chinese contract. What should I do with it? I won`t know what to do.. .